Fusion Drive on External SSD Now, or Wait for Price Drop?
Motivation
I once was a veteran Linux user and knew the benefit of Logical Volume manager (LVM). To be simple, it can make several physical disks merged into one drive and you can manage the adding, removing and replacing of physical disk dynamically. Time machine require 2-3 times larger than your working harddisk. Even though multiple disks can be used in Time machine backup, because Time machine store the initial image on individual disks, if your working disk image too large, there’s not much room for “addition modification images”. Fusion drive, is a tiered harddisks/software combination solution in Mountain Lion. Apple released it in 2012 iMac and Mac mini. A hack make it available on older Mac models.. The disk reading/writing boost does attract me, but as a customer whose iMac is still under AppleCare protection, I believe in that most of Mac users in my condition won’t take the risk to open their mystery Mac box and do the trick to add an internal SSD. To summarize, I need a solution:
- an external tiered storage system, which can combine my mobile disk and reuse them.
- If it’s possible, an alternative solution to Fusion drive is good too.
- As little tricks as possible. I know a lot of workarounds may work, but all of them may introduce new bugs which need new workarounds.
Benchmark
Firstly I would like to calculate what maximum rate I can get from each interface. According to harddsk performance report of iMac 2011, my model speed is around 160~170 (MB/s). I pick up review from Tom’s hardware, seems performace vary in a quite large gap.
But I use Blackmagic Disk Speed Test to test my own 7200rpm HDD WDC WD1001FALS-403AA0 in iMac 2011 27 inch box.

My benchmark seems not good and not consistent with this post. How about others? Fusion drive in 2012 iMac can achieve Write: 249 and Read: 382 (MB/s).
Thunderbolt or not?
Thunderbolt (TB) is still a synonym to expensive. If I buy USB 3.0 external disk, then I need a TB to USB 3.0 dock/hub. According to wiki, there are 3 available docks right now.
- Belkin Thunderbolt Express Dock
- Price: 400USD without TB cable
- Matrox DS1
- Price: 249USD without TB cable
- Sunix Thunderbolt Dock
- Price: not available
Other manufacturers not listed in wikipedia:
The price is insane. 400USD can cover the gap between 2011 iMac and 2012 iMac, and it’s certainly overpriced.
External HDD/SDD performance
- Western Digital My Book Studio 3TB WDBC3G0030HAL
- Performance:read speed of 88.1MB/s and a write speed of 78.6MB/s
- Price: 1390HKD
- Interface which achieves the speed: Firewire800
- Toshiba Canvio Desk 3TB (HDWC130XK3J1)
- Performance: read speed of 147.4 MB/s and a write speed of 136.8 MB/s.
- Price : 146.94USD
- Interface which achieves the speed: USB 3.0
- Western Digital My Book Essential 4TB (WDBACW0040HBK)
- Performance: 126.1MB/s on sequential write and 127.4 MB/s on sequential read
- Price:200USD
- Interface which achieves the speed: USB 3.0
- Elgato Thunderbolt SSD
- Performance: files written at 184MB/s and read at 170.7MB/s
- [Price: 280USD for 120GB]
- Interface which achieves the speed: Thunderbolt
- LaCie Little Big Disk
- Performance : 70 MB/sec reads and 250 MB/sec writes
- Price: 330USD
- Interface which achieves the speed: Thunderbolt
- Seagate GoFlex Desk Thunderbolt Adapter (STAE122)
- Paired with Intel SSD 520
- Paired with 1TB FreeAgent GoFlex portable hard drive
- Price for GoFlex Adapter:94USD
- Akitio Neutrino Thunderbolt Edition
- Performance: read at 464MB/s and write at 311MB/s
- Price: 250USD 120GB SSD including TB cable
- Interface which achieves the speed: Thunderbolt
Fusion Drive on older Mac
As I mentioned previously. It’s seems viable to make older Mac support Fusion drive, but it may be not stable.
1 2 3 4 | |
The author also claimed that Fusion drive can combine external SSD/HDD or even 2 HDD together, sounds promising. Follow up guide points out one note need to pay attention:
- Do Not Use a Drive Made Up of Multiple Partitions
Alternatives Tiered storage on Mac
Disk Utility is handy and Logical Volume Group (LVG) in Mac was introduced in Lion, named CoreStorage. IBM developerWorks has a good explanation to LVG. Other than native OS X LVG, we can setup an NAS Linux host and connect to it via network. Actually, there is commercially available products.
Due to the native support, other 3rd party solutions seem not necessary. Raid 0, surely a viable solution, and there are many on the market. For instance, Lacie.
ZFS itself, is not only a filesystem but also LVG. MacZFS is the implement right now and in there site there is clear history description about ZFS on Mac. Alex Blewitt, the original MacZFS engineer, considers this implementation already stable.
Summary
It is relatively cheap to make a SSD+adapter solution, but the overall price still as high as 250USD. At this stage, I’m better staying at what I really need: a larger Time Machine backup disk. A Western Digital My Book Studio 3TB WDBC3G0030HAL seems a rather good choice. In the future, if the thunderbolt price drops to an affordable level, then surely I want to enjoy the benefit of high speed storage. Thunderbolt adapter with 2 SATA interfaces, and pre-formatted to form a single Fusion Drive combining SSD and HDD, would be very attractive.